The Catalogue of Errors Ltd uses human and artificial intelligence to audit research in the humanities and social sciences. As case studies, you can see our audits of an article in the Financial Times on the link between smartphones and fertility decline and an academic article on the medieval origins of antisemitism in Nazi Germany.

If you would like us to work on a project for you, please write to us at contact@isitcredible.com. Any work we do for you will be private and will not appear on this site.

Reviewer 2

We have also made available our automated text assessment system, Reviewer 2. You can use the most up-to-date version for a small fee below, while you can also install an older version on an Apache 2.0 license. For the theory behind our system, see the paper "Yell At It: Prompt Engineering for Automated Peer Review." Our system compares favourably to other systems, such as refine.ink. You can set up an account to use it or pay for individual jobs. It is also available as an API. See our frequently asked questions for further details.


Drop your PDFs here to begin:

Configure your audit:

Reviewer 2's report, with an emphasis on issues relating to research design and interpretation.

Reviewer 2 will pay closer attention to any equations and derivations, checking for consistency.

An Editor's Note provides guidance on how to respond to Reviewer 2's report; includes proofreading.

A Data Editor audits the code in the replication package.

Disclaimer: Reviewer 2 is an AI-powered system and may hallucinate errors or misinterpret text. It is intended for educational purposes only. Your uploaded files are deleted as soon as the report is generated.

Sign in or create an account to pay with your balance (opens in new tab).

— or pay by card —

0%